WESTON, Mass. — Don't judge a basketball game by its final score.
Wednesday's premier matchup between Tilton, our third-ranked NEPSAC team, and fourth-ranked Loomis Chaffee didn't see a ton of shots fall — it was super entertaining because of the relentless defensive effort from both teams. The Rams trailed narrowly throughout the first half, used a 10-2 run to take the lead in the third quarter, and hung on late for a 45-38 victory at Rivers.
"This win today, on the road especially and having to grind it out — it means the world," Tilton coach Tara Brisson said. "Because now I think the confidence skyrockets, their belief in each other skyrockets, and they know what I've been trying to tell them all year: 'You are so good defensively that you will stay in every single game. Once you can put it together on the offensive end, we'll be really scary.'"
Brisson didn't want to give away the Pelicans' secrets, but she described how challenging it is to face their zone, which is arranged as a 2-3 but incorporates man-to-man principles.
"You just have to not hold the ball above your head and attack, that way you can draw and actual defender and kick, and be able to get somebody with their feet set," she said. "I think we did a much better job of that in the second half, although I thought in the first half we got good shots — we just weren't making them."
Here are five standouts from the matchup.
Colleen Phiri, Tilton
Class of 2025, 5-11 guard/forward
Hometown: Haverhill, Mass.
NCAA: Colgate
In a low-scoring contest, the Colgate commit still managed a game-high 17 points. She hit three 3-pointers that looked quick and effortless off the catch. I was even more impressed by Phiri's effort defensively. She had the Alicia Mitchell matchup most of the game — a good six-inch height difference — and though Mitchell scored some, Phiri contained her successfully. She ripped away one steal during Mitchell's post move and denied an entry pass to force a turnover.
"She is special, and also is the ultimate teammate," Brisson said. "She's the kid that I say, 'You're not just a scorer. You've got to defend, sometimes, the hardest position. You've got to rebound. You've got to do this, this, everything.' (And she says) 'Yes coach. Yes coach.'"
Bela Cucuta, Tilton
Class of 2026, 5-10 guard
Hometown: Newington, Conn.
Six of Cucuta's nine points game at the free-throw line, but they were necessary, as she did a better job of driving and breaking down Loomis Chaffee's stout defense in the second half. Cucuta only made one 3-ball, but her track record as one of NEPSAC's elite shooters lets me cast that aside as an off game. She does of good job of moving without the basketball and spacing the floor, even though she's the team's primary point guard.
Hannah Lynch, Tilton
Class of 2025, 5-10 guard/forward
Hometown: Nashua, N.H.
NCAA: St. Anselm
The entire Rams team deserves credit for its defense, but Lynch's effort and versatility were among the most impactful parts. Perhaps the swing play of the game came when Loomis Chaffee had a transition layup, the player up-faked to send two defenders by and seemed to have a wide open bucket — if not for Lynch pursuing the play and blocking the shot. She also did great job defending smaller, quicker Pelicans point guard Abby Congdon.
"We don't win without her," Brisson said. "... It's not her stat line ever. It's, 'What do I need to do to help the team win?'"
Alicia Mitchell, Loomis Chaffee
Class of 2025, 6-4 center
Hometown: Springfield, Mass.
NCAA: Columbia
Even in the loss, Mitchell (10 points) demonstrated why she's one of New England's elite bigs and perhaps the region's best true center. She's a strong and smooth post scorer, hitting tough layups through contact or fading away for soft jumpers. Mitchell also deserves significant defensive credit. Not only was she blocking shots and protecting the rim, but she also had to rotate out to the corners as part of Loomis Chaffee's zone, and she consistently hustled to her spots.
Catherine Chadwell, Loomis Chaffee
Class of 2025, 6-0 guard/forward
Hometown: Longmeadow, Mass.
NCAA: Swarthmore
Chadwell was fun to watch throughout this game, but especially in the first half when Loomis Chaffee had the lead. She played fantastic off-ball defense, rotating properly within the scheme and racking up a ton of weak-side pass deflections and steals. Chadwell's eight points included a sweet step-through layup; she also put in good effort on the boards.


