John McNamara was initially uncertain if he wanted to pursue the head-coaching vacancy at Newton North. More than anyone, he understood the big shoes he’d have to fill after the sudden departure of Paul Connolly – who stepped down after 24 legendary seasons on March 18 – and the weight of responsibility that comes with leading one of the best MIAA boys basketball programs.
But ultimately, it was an opportunity McNamara couldn’t pass on, especially given how close it is to his heart. McNamara, who’s been part of the program since he was 8 years old, was a member of Newton North’s 2005 state championship team before returning to the school in 2009, when he’s coached at various levels of the program since. On May 22, after multiple rounds of interviews and a process he described as a “whirlwind” following Connolly’s resignation, McNamara was announced as the Tigers’ new head coach.
“I think I would have regretted it if I hadn’t gone through the process,” McNamara said. “Obviously now I’m really glad I did. I’m excited to get started and kind of put my own mark on things and continue the success we’ve had.”
It will certainly be a high standard for McNamara to sustain. Connolly left his mark as one of the best coaches in state history as he amassed 456 career victories, including back-to-back state titles in 2005 and 2006. He nearly captured a third last season after leading Newton North to 24 wins and a berth in the state championship game, where the Tigers lost to Franklin in a thriller.
McNamara feels ready for the challenge, and in many ways is the perfect successor to Connolly. He was captain of the 2005 state championship team, and after his return to the school, he has worked essentially every coaching job within the basketball program. He’s been a volunteer, freshman team head coach and assistant, and junior varsity head coach and assistant. He’s been the JV head coach for the last five seasons, and a varsity assistant under Connolly when he didn’t have JV obligations.
During the interview process, McNamara expressed how deeply important the program is to him. Most of his adult life has in some ways been dedicated to it.
“It's one of the several things in my life that I really care about, so I want to see the program do well, and obviously now being in charge of it, I feel some sense of responsibility to uphold what we’ve built,” McNamara said. “I think when people hear that, they probably think like, ‘Oh, he means we want to win a state championship or win all these games.’ We do want to win, but I think what we’re going to do is continue to build on the right things and the wins and losses will take care of themselves and the success will take care of itself if we continue to preach the right things and have the kids doing the right things.”
McNamara has a good foundation to work from. Connolly has not only been a mentor for him, but someone he now considers a close friend. He joked that their coaching styles will be a bit different – McNamara joked that he’ll probably be a little calmer than Connolly – but he’ll set many of the same building blocks as his longtime predecessor.
“We’ve kind of built the whole thing off of kids being selfless and sacrificing for the team and putting the team first,” McNamara said. “I think one thing that’s always separated us and my hope is that it will never change, is that we pride ourselves on how hard we play and how hard we compete. It sounds cliche, but it’s not cliche because I think it’s something that we really hang our hat on and we instill in the kids, and it’s something that we talk about all the time and it’s something the kids buy into as well. …
“I like to think I’m a warm demander. We’re going to hold the kids accountable and be hard on them but also have conversations and make sure the kids are feeling valued and feeling good about what we’re doing. I like to think I coach with a lot of intensity, but also able to meet the kids’ needs wherever they’re at.”
McNamara is stepping into the job at an exciting time for the program. Newton North will graduate a few key pieces from last season’s state finalists – including Teagan Swint and Nick Spinelli – but he’ll bring back 10 returners, several of whom played significant minutes last season and earned valuable experience in big games. It’s not yet June, but he said some of the kids are already talking about getting back to the final game next season.
McNamara knows it’s a little too early to be thinking about that, but the excitement is palpable as a new era begins at Newton North.
“We call those more like dreams as opposed to goals, winning the state championship or whatever,” McNamara said. “The way we’re gonna hopefully be successful is by just trying to be present and taking it one day at a time and not try to accomplish that dream on the first day of tryouts, it’s not going to happen that way. But I’m excited. We have a really good core group of guys and our young guys are talented and we have a pretty deep group that I think a lot of guys will be able to play and contribute. I’m fired up. You can tell they’re chomping at the bit to get it going. I wish we were starting tomorrow because they’re that into it and they want to get to work.”


