About seven rows above the court at the Track at New Balance last November, John Clancy sat next to Jeff Moesch for a season-opening weekend game between Cushing and CATS, and they experienced some déjà vu.
Moesch’s son Ryan – who they had both coached at Chittenango High School in New York – was making his NEPSAC debut for Cushing, and the two longtime friends made the trip to Boston. Ryan, a 6-foot guard, initially struggled. Clancy thought he was tentative in the first half, and Jeff saw his son have a hard time adjusting to a level of athleticism, physicality and length he had never seen before. Cushing trailed by as many as 19 in the second half.
But then somewhere, something clicked for Ryan. A scene unfolded before that Jeff and Clancy were all-too-familiar with, as Ryan started taking over and willing Cushing to a comeback.
“We looked at each other and were like, ‘OK, here we go,’” Clancy said.
“It was about four minutes left in that game. … I looked at Jeff and said to him, ‘I’d rather be down five with Ryan Moesch rather than being up five without him.’”
Moments later, he made the play of the game and proved him right. Ryan denied a ball screen at the left wing before using his quickness to split two defenders and get in the paint. He had just one man in front of him – CATS 7-foot-1 center Leo Curtis – and attacked him at the rim, rising up to finish a jaw-dropping three-point play as he crashed to the court. Laying on his back, Ryan clenched his fists and screamed.
“I’ve always been overlooked and I want to prove myself,” Ryan said. “It’s basically just all instincts and me just trying to win and be the winner that I am.”
Overlooked no more. Ryan ultimately led Cushing to a thrilling overtime victory that day, which set the stage for a breakout winter in which he emerged as one of New England’s most electrifying guards. A cerebral playmaker and fearless competitor, Ryan Moesch is appointment viewing.
“He’s worth the price of admission,” said Michael Crotty, the director of Middlesex Magic. “He’s that kind of hooper.”
House rules
To understand why Ryan is so fearless and excels against bigger players, look no further than the mini basketball court in the basement of their old home in Cazenovia, N.Y., where he would have nightly battles with his older brother Alex, who has always been bigger and stronger. Jeff sat on the stairwell, watching them beat up on each other.
“One of them would come up crying, it would usually be Ryan,” Jeff joked.
Ryan was a lefty and Alex was a righty, so Jeff created a game where they would get two points for an off-handed layup and one for a strong-handed score. These battles, he felt, taught them skillwork, footwork and finishing. For Ryan, toughness was required to beat his brother.
NEW MAG: Check out our June 2025 edition
Jeff knew Ryan was different when he was 3 years old, when he watched him rip baseballs with a whiffle bat on their front lawn. His hand-eye coordination was elite. Jeff said Ryan was even better at lacrosse, but basketball always came first, and it showed. By seventh grade, he was telling his dad he was going to prep school, and it was clear big things were ahead as he played two levels up on youth teams and continued to excel against bigger kids.
In eighth grade, at the high school gym in Cazenovia, Ryan put up a piece of tape that said ‘D1’ on it. He always looked up at it when he took a shot as a reminder of his goal.
“He always knew he wanted to see how far he could go with it,” Jeff said.
When Ryan was in ninth grade, the family moved to neighboring Chittenango, where he and Alex – who is two years older than him – played for Clancy, the head coach, and their dad, who was an assistant. Ryan’s great potential could be seen as a freshman. He started, played more off the ball and helped Chittenango win a sectional championship.
In his sophomore year, Ryan took even greater leaps – literally.
Clancy remembers it vividly. During a three-week stretch from mid-December 2022 to early January 2023, Ryan “went from being a good athlete to an elite athlete.” He went from almost being able to dunk to tomahawking with two hands.
“I don’t know if something just popped or something just clicked,” Clancy said. “All of a sudden, it was like, nobody could really guard him before, but now two guys couldn’t guard him. He just got so athletic.”
In a game against Bishop Ludden – ironically, a team that featured Chad Cook, who’s now his teammate with the Middlesex Magic – Clancy remembers a memorable play. Ryan, who was 5-foot-10 at the time, had a fast break with a big 6-foot-8 player in his way and nearly dunked on him. It missed, but it left Clancy amazed.
“He was up there,” Clancy said. “I remember looking at Jeff on the bench and saying, ‘OK, that’s a little different than what we’ve been seeing.’ … (I thought) he’s always been special but this is a different level of being special.”
Jeff said that fearlessness is part of what’s always made him special.
“He’s always kind of had that (mindset of), ‘I don’t care who you are, I’m going to come right at you and I’m going to score on you,’” Jeff said. “He’s always had that little (expletive) in him.”
When Ryan was a junior, several of Chittenango’s top players graduated – including Alex, who went on to play at Hobart – and he was given the full keys. With a lack of weapons around him, they revamped the offense so that Ryan was always shooting or passing for a bucket. He averaged about 38 points per game – including multiple 50-point outbursts – as he saw every kind of defense imaginable, from box and ones to triangle and twos. It was clear he was ready for a different challenge.
The next chapter
Cushing head coach James Cormier had been tipped about Ryan back in 2023, and having a hole to fill at point guard heading into last season, he circled back. Through a connection at Le Moyne – where Cormier played, and the first school to offer Ryan a scholarship – Cormier took a trip to Chittenango to work him out. He was immediately blown away by his attention to detail.
“On the phone, he’s a quiet reserved kid, but once he gets between the lines, he just wants to be great,” Cormier said.
“I’d be like, ‘Here’s a suggestion I got for you,’ and he would follow up like, ‘This you mean? Like this?’ And I’m like, ‘(Expletive), he already figured this stuff out.’ That was three reps he got at it. This kid really cares about getting better.”
Before the season, Cormier said Ryan would be the most polarizing player in New England because of his ability despite his size – and his new point guard backed that up. After those initial growing pains that game against CATS, Ryan blossomed. With a talented squad around him, he led Cushing to the NEBL championship as the MVP, the NEPSAC Class AA regular-season title and the semifinals of the national prep championship. The Penguins went 26-6, scored wins over some of the best prep teams in the nation, and Ryan was often the best player on the court.
“His pace is better than anyone that I’ve seen,” Cormier said. “The best offense you can run with Ryan Moesch is get the ball in his hands as fast as possible and space the floor. … He’s why we go, but just the commitment from his teammates to buy into that and trust him, trust our philosophy is where you saw us really grow.”
WAITING GAME: How the NCAA transfer portal has impacted high school recruiting in New England
Ryan’s intangibles shined throughout the winter, too. His fearless competitiveness had always been there – and it showed under the bright lights, when he was never fazed by big moments – but his emotional leadership grew. He always played with great joy, and it rubbed off on the rest of his team. Every game, no matter the stakes, mattered to him. Wild celebrations ensued after big wins – including their victory over Newman at TD Garden – and he wore his emotions if they lost. It came from an undying love for his teammates and coaches.
“He plays for his teammates,” Cormier said. “If he plays a bad game and we win, you won’t know. If he plays a good game and he loses, he is devastated. You don’t see that anymore. …
“He's so quiet (but) he has this alter ego when he just wants to encourage and motivate and win and he wants to do it for everyone. It’s pretty special.”
A unique prospect
Ryan is such a one-of-a-kind player, it’s hard to describe him. Even his dad has trouble sometimes.
“I can’t put my finger on it,” Jeff said. “I’ve watched him my whole life. I don’t know what it is, but you have to watch it to see it.”
He said even college coaches who have seen him can’t put their finger on what makes him different or special. It’s probably because there isn’t one thing. It’s the quick twitchiness, change of speed and direction. There’s the sneaky elite athleticism. He can read every defense, play in any coverage and understands the nuances that can separate him for any play. He can make every pass. His instincts might be his most impressive trait; he seems to always be one step ahead of the defense.
“He just has the sense of when and how to get it there when even the defense seems to know that’s where it’s going,” Crotty said. “Once in a while, he’ll just throw a pass that no one sees coming and I didn’t even see.”
There are certainly areas for him to improve. More consistent shooting from deep and guarding his position are among them, but he’s shown growth in both. He’s undoubtedly a Division 1 prospect; as of late May, he had nearly 20 offers, mostly from mid-majors. His coaches believe he has high-major potential. Crotty can’t help but compare him to Tyler Kolek, another lefty guard he coached with the Magic who now plays for the New York Knicks.
“Kolek had everyone’s respect and around New England in a short period of time, I think Ryan Moesch got everyone’s respect,” Crotty said. “When you’re going to play a game and he’s your point guard, you’re feeling pretty excited about coaching the game, I’ll say that.”
Cormier thinks Ryan’s consistency is why he can play at the highest level of college basketball. Whenever a coach comes to watch him play, Cormier is never worried about a bad performance.
“Ryan Moesch is going to score 15-28 points, he’s going to have six to 12 assists, he’s going to run your offense, keep guys accountable,” Cormier said. “He’s very much the same guy and has a similar impact. (I tell coaches), ‘Come watch him play. He’s going to be good.’”
So far, he hasn’t done anything to suggest otherwise.
“He is a savant,” Clancy said. “Just like people who can play the violin, maybe they studied music or whatever, but some people can just pick up a violin and it sounds unbelievable. Whatever you need to play basketball, his brain is wired perfectly for that.”


