Christine Brissette recently completed her first full grassroots basketball parenting journey, watching as her oldest daughter, Izzy Adams, grew into a Division 1 prospect with Mass Premier, the Honey Badgers and finally MCW Starz.
At the end of the summer season, Brissette joined several other parents for a dinner where they reflected on their years spent in AAU. Would they do it all over again? She said yes, but the answers were mixed, and the table talk was honest.
“At the end of the day, your daughter is playing, doing her passion, and hopefully going to school for free or close to it,” Brissette said. “And sometimes I don't know — like, the amount of money we put into it, I probably could have paid for two or three years of most colleges.”
AAU basketball participation has become an expectation for anyone hoping to play at a high level. That plus scholastic hoops creates a near-year-round calendar that demands time, effort and a significant financial investment.
It’s no secret that in basketball, the fees to join a team and travel with it typically reach into the thousands.
The question for many families becomes: How early am I supposed to hop on this AAU train?
“There is absolutely, I think, a pressure for kids to play club, no matter what sport it is, at a very young age,” said Justin Kittredge, father of Medfield and now-Nobles star Izzy Kittredge. “I think that parents, probably a lot of them, feel the pressure that if you don't start doing club at a young age, you're going to get behind.”
Adams and Kittredge, plus their parents, have contrasting journeys that exemplify the challenges families face. The bottom line: There’s no right answer on when to commit to AAU, but be prepared to make sacrifices regardless.
Izzy Adams’ early AAU experience
Adams has been obsessed with basketball since kindergarten. The Walpole, Mass., native dominated in her rec leagues to the point that parents started to complain she was too good. Brissette knew nothing about how AAU worked, but she found the closest program with stability, Mass Premier, and signed her daughter up in third grade.
From there, Adams played up with older girls and held her own. She then switched to the Honey Badgers, a small but competitive AAU program that included several future MIAA standouts. Adams stayed with the Honey Badgers through the end of her junior year at Walpole, then joined MCW Starz in the search for a more prominent exposure platform (she also transferred to Dexter Southfield and reclassified).
“I think (starting early) definitely helped me, because, in high school, you're playing with girls who take it seriously and play AAU and girls who just play high school. I have a bunch of years under my belt already, and I feel like they're just starting to learn those things, and I've already mastered those things,” she said. “So I do think, even though it's a big commitment, even starting really young and getting into all of it earlier, that definitely put me at an advantage when I got to the high school level.”
Adams, a 5-foot-8 point guard, counts court vision and basketball I.Q. among her signature strengths. She says those standout traits exist in part because she was playing against tough competition from a young age.
“Every program is going to run differently and has its advantages and disadvantages, but I think I've kind of gotten a good mix,” she said. “I've learned a lot from every program I've been on, so I think that's all added into how I play now.”
Adams made friends in all three AAU programs who she still talks to today. With MCW, she’s also a role model in a large program for the younger kids in the pipeline, who get to watch Adams and the rest of the elite players in the high-pressure showcase games they’ll one day join.
“They're getting used to it, because in a couple years, they're going to be on the big stage and they're going to have a little bit of that experience under their belt,” Adams said. “Even them being there and being able to watch us — just like the environment that they're in is kind of a reflection of what it's going to be in a few years.”
Brissette didn’t know what her family was getting into when Adams first started playing travel ball. College wasn’t on the radar at all, so she and Adams had to learn the ins and outs of the grassroots recruiting world through experience. When Brissette is forking over more than $900 in a 12-day span to watch Adams play in Ohio (her estimate from the last July live period), suddenly the decisions about what program to play for and how to maximize exposure became a lot more serious.
Brissette watched that tension build around her during that final July weekend.
“I was thinking, ‘This is our last (showcase). It's gonna be great; it's just gonna be all fun,’” she said. “But you could feel all the parents’ energy of, like, where's my kid going? Are they gonna get an offer? There was so much stress.”
Brissette is a mother of four and Adams is the most talented of the bunch so far. But going through the entire process with her oldest daughter has made Brissette rethink her approach with her younger children.
“I don't think it's for every kid, so I think every family would answer differently. Isabelle has always been strong on and off the court and can handle all this pressure, but I've seen other kids where it breaks them,” Brissette said. “And so I don't know. I think I would do it again for Isabelle, but for some of my other kids, I'm not doing it because I just know each kid's different, and they couldn't handle it.
“If you're not playing D1, I don't think you should go all in at a high-level club. Stay local. Do some fun tournaments.”
Izzy Kittredge started later — and took on the spring sport dilemma
Kittredge has inherited the two sports her parents played, basketball and lacrosse, and reached local stardom. She won state championships in both basketball and lacrosse at Medfield this year.
Basketball has always taken a slight priority and is the sport Kittredge wants to play in college. But she loves lacrosse and its importance to her family; Kittredge wears No. 25 on the field to honor her grandfather, a former Johns Hopkins player.
“Basketball and lacrosse are so much more similar than people think. They play such similar styles,” she said. “It's really nice to have something else you can kind of escape to like lacrosse. I don't really take it that seriously, because I know I'm not going to be playing in college, so I think I just have fun with it, and that just makes it such a great experience.”
Kittredge’s parents never pressured her to pick one, though both she and Justin said they notice a societal expectation to specialize. She first took AAU basketball seriously in eighth grade with the Bay State Jaguars, and looking back now, Kittredge is glad she joined when she did.
“I feel like exposure too young can really be hard on someone and doesn't really allow you to explore what you might truly want,” she said. “I think in sixth grade, I had no idea what sport I wanted to play, and I feel like AAU is something you choose when you want to be dialed into the sport. So I think overall — AAU is a big commitment. But I think if you want to get to play at the next level, you have to make that decision to play there.”
Kittredge says she knew friends who dropped out of AAU and basketball altogether because that commitment was too great, and because they faced pressure to be consumed by the sport.
“I think it's good for a girl to explore the different sports or what they actually love, because if girls are thrown into AAU if they're in like, fourth grade (or) fifth grade, and are only seeing one sport, they're obviously going to only look at one sport. And I hate to say this, but you might actually stop loving it if they're surrounded by it all the time,” she said.
“So I think it's really important for girls to find the balance to have AAU, but also make sure you're having fun while you're still young and exploring sports where you can just let loose a little bit, because sometimes it can be stressful and put pressure on yourself to perform.”
But spring sports are a particularly difficult problem because they overlap directly with most of the grassroots calendar. It meant Kittredge had to make multiple tough sacrifices this year — including locking in her Nobles transfer the day after winning a state championship with Medfield.
“That was the hardest decision I’ve probably ever had to make,” Kittredge said.
Two days after her 28-point performance in that MIAA Div. 2 title game, Kittredge tried out for Medfield’s lacrosse team. AAU was mere weeks from tip-off. The MIAA prohibits athletes from missing school practices or games for non-school sports like clubs; Kittredge actually missed one lacrosse practice for an AAU tournament and couldn’t start the next game.
At the same time, Kittredge was also making local AAU showcases, but skipping important ones like the Atlantic City Showcase during the May live recruiting period. Last year, Kittredge competed on the Jaguars’ top Under Armour circuit squad for her age group. She actually moved down to a secondary team this year because she was losing playing time and she felt bad about missing so many practices.
“The question was, if you really want to give basketball a shot and go to the best school you can possibly go to for you, whatever that fit is, then it's really hard,” Justin said. “Going into senior year, you either need to probably stop playing lacrosse, or you need to just reclass at some point. And she just wasn't ready to quit lacrosse, which I think was great, and I'm really glad that she still has that love for both sports. But it was a really, really hard decision to make.”
Lacrosse and AAU practically forced Kittredge’s hand in transferring to Nobles. By reclassifying to 2027, she gets an extra year of exposure in AAU and prep school that she had been missing out on, and Nobles will more easily allow her to play both sports at the same time. She ends her time at Medfield as a two-time state champ in both basketball and lacrosse.
“I love Medfield so much. I love the people, I love the coaches, I love all of my teammates, and I think it was really hard for that (reason), because I had to really think about what I really want for my future and what I wanted to put first,” Kittredge said.
Does extra AAU experience matter in recruiting?
College coaches are not out scouting 8-year-old phenoms. The Adams and Kittredge families felt that recruiting generally started to enter the picture around eighth grade or freshman year for most talented players. But do schools care if you’ve played longer?
Katie Nelson knows both sides. The Falmouth, Mass., native is currently a Boston University assistant coach who has been on staff at Gardner-Webb and Wisconsin. She’s also a former BU star who went through the same development process, starting in early elementary school and playing AAU through high school.
“I think for me, being in that competitive environment and being able to play against higher-level teams (helped), or you can play up and play older kids, which is similar to college,” she said. “You're coming in as a freshman playing against seniors or fifth-years that are four or five years older than you. So it can kind of give it that competitive feel at a younger age.”
Nelson acknowledged that players competing on a high-level AAU team by eighth or ninth grade are logically going to get seen by scouts and have their names on college radars earlier. But that doesn’t put them at a hypothetical front of the line. She added that post players, for example, often catch up to their potential later, or those with innate athletic gifts.
Think about NBA star Joel Embiid, who very quickly became a top high school prospect long before his MVP career despite not playing basketball until age 15. Or look locally: Fope Ayo, New England’s top 2026 prospect, didn’t start playing basketball until she was 12 years old. Both also have unteachable size and athleticism for their position.
“Everyone has a different gift and natural ability, and some kids have more of a natural ability, so that can afford for them to start a little bit later,” Nelson said. “I think it really is just case-by-case and person-to-person, which is difficult, right? It's difficult because as a parent, you want to give your kid the best opportunity. But I think it's hard to sometimes be realistic with that.”
Nelson believes there’s no right answer for when kids should start playing. But she also emphasized that AAU doesn’t have to just be mapped out in the pursuit of a scholarship. The maturation experience can still be rewarding for athletes and their families, even if it doesn’t lead to college hoops.
“You're still getting a lot of life skills from playing a competitive sport and on a team and traveling, and there's so many different aspects that you're being taught at a young age,” she said. “How to travel, how to be polite at a restaurant, how to order food, how to manage your sleep and recovery. How to be on a team and work together and fight for a role that you might want, or learn how to be happy in a role, and communicate and take feedback.”
Separating the club experience from the end goal is hard though, especially with thousands of dollars going into AAU to potentially reap tens of thousands or more down the line. That’s why Nelson said that, especially if athletes are going to play at a young age, it’s on parents to set reasonable goals and make sure the sport is fun first.
“You have to have real expectations of your child (and) how they're experiencing AAU,” she added. “Are they enjoying it? Is it becoming a job? Because when you're 13, you don't want to have to think of AAU tournaments as a job.”


