BROOKLINE, Mass. — Wednesday's NEPSAC girls Class AAA matchup between Dexter Southfield and Newman highlighted a handful of New England's top young college prospects. But don't just take my word for it!
Shane Laflin, Premier Basketball Report director and ESPN girls basketball national analyst, was in the house. Laflin joined us on the HoopWise Podcast following the travel season in August, and explained that scholastic hoops provides a different environment to grow and evaluate compared to AAU.
"You can still gain things from being a leader, making sure that your teammates feel better than they are, supporting them and pointing out the positive things that they're doing," he said. "Because you're going to be that guy when you're a freshman in college who thinks you can't do anything right, and you're going to want that junior or senior to be telling you, 'Hey, you are doing it right. Even though you're really screwing up our drill right now, you're getting better.' There's stuff to be gained from either one, so I just kind of watch the context."
Dexter Southfield took a 24-12 lead through a sluggish first half, but as both teams picked up the scoring pace, Newman kept the gap close in an ultimate 56-48 Dexter win. Here are five standouts from the matchup, including Laflin's thoughts on a few of the prospects.
Avery Bollin, Dexter Southfield
Class of 2029, 6-3 forward
Hometown: Raynham, Mass.
Bollin may have finished with only six points, but I again thought we got some glimpses at what makes her such an advanced post player for her age. She has the post spin move into her left-hand finish down pat and looks comfortable driving into that move as well. I'd like to see her build in some counters as defenses try to take that move away, but Bollin is still strong enough to force her way to her spots. She also showed great chemistry with fellow big Brooke Nunnally-Gardner (more on her in a bit), and twice found her on interior passes for assists after drawing help or a double-team.
Again, Bollin's communication and effort on defense popped, something Laflin noted in particular.
"That was the best defensive effort – complete — that I've probably seen. Just rotationally, I think she did a good job," he said. "Bigs, early on in their career when they're younger, they play a lot of drop coverage stuff. I saw some good hedges, some good X-outs between her and Ella (Peper) tonight. I've talked to Avery — she's got such a loud voice and a big personality that she should be constantly talking defensively, and I saw some of that tonight, so I thought those were really positive things."
Ella Peper, Dexter Southfield
Class of 2028, 6-4 guard/forward
Hometown: Newton, Mass.
Peper struck early with a long jumper off a screen, a step-back 2 and a catch-and-shoot 3 in the first quarter. She also battled a face-guard from Ayla Keefe (more on her too) for most of the game. finishing with 16 points. I did think that during the second half, Peper stepped up her aggression level in the post and established better positioning for short fadeaways. She also got out and running in transition as a scorer and passer where she's most lethal. Defensively, she continues to cover ridiculous amounts of ground with her speed and length, which led to a monster help block on a drive and several deflections guarding the perimeter.
Laflin and I have both followed Peper's growth as a physically imposing star. He noted she's improving at battling for defensive rebounds, but also saw how her post touches infrequently led to actual shots at the rim. Laflin has Peper ranked as the No. 4 prospect in the national 2028 class; he's clearly high on her trajectory. But he offered an honest assessment of where she needs to grow.
"That's part of imposing your physicality, is that (if) you go make a cut to the rim (and) you're denied, you spin and pin and you demand the basketball. You get an easy bucket. You get a foul," Laflin said. "You can't come out of a game not having a couple O-boards and putbacks. We talked about that. One or two a quarter, and you're keeping 12-to-16 points in your pocket, and that's before you hit a 3. Yeah, you know. Again, I'm talking more or less habits for the future, things that you do. Refuse blockouts — you don't accept block-outs. You go to the rim. Offensively, you rebound out of your area. All those things, these are just things that should happen relentlessly all the time, and habitually, you would like to start seeing some of that."
Brooke Nunnally-Gardner, Dexter Southfield
Class of 2026, 6-0 forward
Hometown: Stoughton, Mass.
NCAA: Cornell
Nunnally-Gardner was the most impactful player in this game, finishing with 17 points and stabilizing Dexter during Newman's second-half comeback attempts. She consistently ran the floor hard in transition as a center and battled for offensive rebounds. That included one putback off a missed free throw and another tip to a teammate from a missed free throw in crunch time that helped Dexter Southfield close out the victory.
I thought Nunnally-Gardner did a great job moving along the low blocks and setting herself up for her teammates, especially on those two assists from Bollin. She even slid her feet with a very quick Shannon Welburn to block her driving layup attempt late in the game. Dexter Southfield is still a very young team, so Nunnally-Gardner's dependability and consistent effort level is so valuable.
Ayla Keefe, Newman

Class of 2028, 5-11 guard/forward
Hometown: Cave Creek, Ariz.
I've now watched three Newman games in the span of a month and Keefe has looked demonstrably better each time. After just two first-half points, Keefe turned up for 19 in the second half, including two made 3-pointers. She's not an especially fast or explosive athlete, but she processes the game at such a high level and is stronger than you'd think. She scored off a face cut and moved well without the ball, but showed more aggression driving it herself in the second half than I've seen before. That included a strong attack into an open driving lane off of a ball screen for a lefty layup; she also scored her first bucket on a step-through layup.
I again saw Keefe make high-level drive-and-kick reads, and defensively, she took on the Ella Peper assignment and did about as well as you could ask.
"It was face-guard, no help; she was talking the whole time," Laflin said. "And then I thought she had points tonight where she was really aggressive, which has been good to watch her kind of unlock that in herself over the course of the last six-to-nine months. So she was assertive. She shot it. She talks a lot on the floor; there's some leadership intangibles. And then like I said, you're a 5-10, 5-11, guard, guarding a 6-4 big, face-guarding, blocking out, working. So she had to work her butt off tonight to get that done. Proud of her — she did a good job. She's turned into a strong player."
Taryn Campbell, Newman

Class of 2026, 6-0 forward
Hometown: Taunton, Mass.
Newman didn't have another high scorer, but I want to give some love to Campbell (five points), who shouldn't go underrated as a Division 2-3 prospect on a deep roster. Her best sequence came when she thwarted a Dexter 2-on-1 in transition with a block at the rim, then canned a spot-up 3 on the Cardinals' next possession. Campbell's a very solid team defender as a power forward-type, and though she doesn't command a ton of touches, she can hit from the perimeter and cut well.


