The Nickerson Showcase at Nobles provided some much-needed clarity on the NEPSAC girls basketball hierarchy — but in many ways, it also made things more confusing.
One thing we know for sure: Class AAA is stacked and evenly-matched. Seven of the eight schools appear in this week's Top 10, including one rankings debutant. Almost every AAA school seems capable of beating each other on a given night and only one is still undefeated.
Also at Nickerson: a Class B Small program took down a Class AAA program in overtime. Multiple Class B Large and Small upsets went down. I'll have multiple servings of individual standouts from Nickerson coming in the next few days, but we'll start with assessing the team pictures via this Top 10 update.
This will also be the last ranking for a few weeks as prep schools enter winter vacations.
1. Tilton (7-0)

Previous rank: 1
Next game: vs. Austin Prep, Jan. 9, 5 p.m.
Unlike pretty much every other team on this list, the Rams got a light Nickerson schedule by comparison and absolutely dominated, beating Rivers, St. Luke's and Sacred Heart each by 30-plus points. Maddie McCaffery (Merrimack, N.H.) crossed 1,000 career points over the weekend. We got to see the depth of impact talent on this roster shine through and the multiple lead playmakers the Rams can turn to. Tilton also traveled to Tabor and prevailed, 72-65, in a very competitive matchup where its zone defense made the difference in the second half.
2. Hoosac (6-3)

Previous rank: 3
Next game: vs. TBD at Westtown (Pa.), Jan. 3, 3 p.m.
Hoosac only played one Nickerson Showcase game, but it was a statement: a 60-52 triumph over host Nobles that marked an extremely rare Bulldogs defeat in their home event. Star guard Anna Moser (Rutland, Vt.) back-cut and relocated over and over to get her 22 points, but Hoosac really wowed with the size, speed and physicality across its rotation. They pushed the lead up to the mid-double digits in the third quarter, sputtered in the fourth and still managed to close out a victory.
This team was big and tough last year, but in my opinion, they've leveled up with their ability to run in transition and create off of cuts beyond Moser. Hoosac hits the road for two more non-NEPSAC games in early January before returning to play out its AAA schedule.
3. Nobles (4-2)

Previous rank: 4
Next game: vs. Dexter Southfield, Jan. 2, 12 p.m.
We learned a lot about the Bulldogs' current state and season-long potential at Nickerson. They gutted out a 53-43 win against Newman on Friday, had a comeback attempt fall short against Hoosac Saturday and then bounced back in a 60-52 win over New Hampton in which Nobles controlled the middle portion of the matchup.
Nobles needs its top offensive players to be consistently assertive for a full game, something we haven't seen yet. But we continue to see different talents step up in different moments — like Izzy Kittredge (Medfield, Mass.) against Newman, Aliyah Allston-Pujols (Randolph, Mass.) leading the comeback attempt Saturday, and Alannah Morantus (North Attleboro, Mass.) and Vanessa Ellis (Attleboro, Mass.) taking charge in Sunday's victory. That's a great sign there's a ton of upside still to be unlocked with this roster.
4. New Hampton (6-1)

Previous rank: 2
Next game: at Kimball Union, Jan. 7, 4:30 p.m.
The Huskies earned double-digit wins against Northfield Mount Hermon and Wilbraham & Monson to start their Nickerson Showcase schedule, but ran out of gas Sunday against Nobles. Elyse Ngenda (Bedford, N.H.) and Serenity Lancaster (New London, N.H.) had to take over after the team trailed by 15 points after three quarters. It took too long for New Hampton to crack Nobles' rotation of strong guard defenders.
That loss aside, I actually thought the supporting cast showed me a lot in the other two games. Ava Perry (Groveland, Mass.) played really well in Friday's victory over NMH, hustling on the boards and knocking down a few big 3s, and 2028 transfer Saige DeJesus (Brockton, Mass.) made an impact with her defense and drives. I'd still put New Hampton in the championship contender tier of AAA — but as you're noticing, that tier is a lot wider than I thought preseason.
5. Tabor (7-2)

Next game: at Lawrence Academy, Jan. 9, 6 p.m.
The Seawolves had the most impressive past week of any team. Before arriving at Nickerson, they went toe-to-toe with Tilton in last Wednesday's home defeat, leading for a good chunk of the game before losing by seven points. Then they arrived at the Nickerson Showcase and rolled through Wilbraham & Monson and Worcester Academy before wrestling away a 60-50 win against a tough Northfield Mount Hermon defense. Corinne Lomax (Watertown, Conn.) scored a Miami offer just before the weekend and dropped jaws with her special athleticism and power throughout the three games.
Tabor has only played Tilton and Hoosac in Class AAA (also its only losses), so I'm excited to see it dig into more Class AAA opponents after winter break.
6. Dexter Southfield (6-2)

Previous rank: 5
Next game: at Nobles, Jan. 2, 12 p.m.
This is where the rankings start getting tricky. Dexter Southfield routed Loomis Chaffee Friday and then won a great, physical game against Darrow, 56-51. But on Sunday, they stumbled in a rematch with Newman, dropping a 57-51 thriller to cap the Nickerson Showcase. Ella Peper (Newton, Mass.) scored 27 in the loss.
I've kept Dexter pretty high in these rankings because I think it still has several quality wins this season: at Northfield Mount Hermon, vs. Newman and then this latest win against Darrow. Sunday's result says a lot about Newman in my opinion (as you'll see), as well as the parity level and collective strength across Class AAA. We'll see how Dexter handles another tough defensive matchup in its next contest against Nobles.
7. Darrow (5-2)

Previous rank: 6
Next week: at Worcester Academy, Jan. 10, 4 p.m.
Saturday's meeting with Dexter Southfield was among my favorite games of the Nickerson Showcase. Darrow showed off its physical, frustrating defense. Jill Dingler (Storrs, Conn.) got buckets en route to 23 points, and transfer Taelor Arnold (East Hartford, Conn.) shined running offense as well. It was a tough loss, but it validated my belief in Darrow as the top non-AAA NEPSAC school. The Ducks also crushed Milton Academy, 82-35, as part of their two-game slate. They did lose prior to Nickerson at home against Wilbraham & Monson, but it was hard to drop the Ducks further than No. 7.
8. Northfield Mount Hermon (6-4)

Previous rank: 7
Next game: at Hoosac, Jan. 7, 4:30 p.m.
This was a challenging week for Northfield Mount Hermon, which dropped games against New Hampton and Tabor that sandwiched a Saturday victory over Kent. NMH hasn't had quite the offensive firepower to knock off the AAA opponents on its schedule (all four losses are to AAA teams) and is still missing Molly Sisson (Rochester, Mass.) due to injury. But they're still defending as well as any team in NEPSAC. Larea Jean-Ross (Concord, Mass.) will definitely get a shoutout in my Nickerson Showcase dispatches for how she defended down the stretch of the Kent victory. It's good to see other lesser-known rotation players stepping up for NMH.
9. Newman (6-5)
Previous rank: NR
Next game: vs. St. Andrew's, Jan. 9, 4:30 p.m.
Talk about a wild weekend. Newman battled against Nobles in a 53-43 loss Friday, then went to overtime Saturday against Hamden Hall before falling apart in a 68-58 defeat. But the Cardinals passed a huge test of resolve by returning Sunday to face Dexter Southfield — a school that had beaten them less than two weeks prior — and capturing a 57-51 victory. It was a true team-wide defensive effort and the best win of the season.
I spoke in last week's rankings about looking for programs to earn statement victories in order to land on this list. Newman had competed hard against top teams but had yet to come out with that kind of W until Sunday. The triumph proved a lot about the Cardinals' capability competing in Class AAA and the general player buy-in under first-year coach Katie Kolinski. Now we'll see what they can sustain.
10. Wilbraham & Monson (6-5)
Previous rank: NR
Next game: at Greens Farms, Jan. 10, 2 p.m.
Similarly, Wilbraham & Monson had a statement victory overshadow some losses — but it was before Nickerson in last Wednesday's 47-43 win at Darrow. The Titans defended at a high level and 2028 center Addison Brennan (Monroe, Conn.) provided her most complete game of the season to that point with 13 points and 15 rebounds.
The Nickerson Showcase was a struggle, as the Titans lost badly to Tabor and a bit more competitively against New Hampton, but they ended on a high note with a win against Choate Sunday. Of WMA's five losses, four have come against Top 10 teams and the fifth was against a healthier Worcester Academy squad that would otherwise be a contender. The Titans are starting to find an identity without star Caterina Ravosa (East Longmeadow, Mass.), who remains out for a while with injury, and it's notable progress for the young roster.
The next five:Â Sacred Heart, Hamden Hall, Kimball Union, Suffield, Austin Prep
The injury bug has sapped the strength of a few programs. Sacred Heart went 1-2 at Nickerson, including a loss to Kimball Union that Eva Wilkerson missed with a head injury, and they also didn't have Lucianna Parrotta at all this weekend. She should return from injury after winter break. Worcester Academy was down to six players at Nickerson with Gracyn Barnes, Ella Getz and Sadie Metzger all out. Those teams will be better when they get healthy.
I nearly ranked Hamden Hall after the Hornets took down Newman, but then they sputtered Sunday in a loss to Brooks — who has previously lost to Kimball Union, who has previously lost to Hamden Hall. Berkshire falls from the Top 10 after two collapses against Governor's and St. George's. Suffield and Austin Prep did not play at Nickerson and are both still relatively untested, and I'm keeping Ethel Walker in the back of my mind as well. St. George's (5-1) is sneaking into the picture after defeating Berkshire and Greens Farms this past week.


